SF’s Best Pizzeria: Tony’s Pizza Napoletana

  Posted by - September 15, 2014 - $$ (20-50), Daytime, NightTime, Restaurants, San Francisco


Let’s talk pizza in San Francisco.

Because. Who doesn’t love pizza?

I mean…



oh.mah.gahh #drooling

When I ask around for the “Best Pizza” in SF, I always hear the name “Tony’s Pizza Napoletana” in North Beach.

But… besides the word of mouth and raving online reviews, let’s quickly go over some of their accolades:

  • Best Pizza Margherita at the World Pizza Cup in Naples, Italy (First American and non Neapolitan to win this award)
  • Best Pizza Romana at the World Championship of Pizza Makers in 2011
  • Voted Best Pizzeria in America by Forbes

And the list goes on…

So. What makes Tony’s so special?

Well… first off, there are 12 distinct styles of pizza (Neapolitan, Classic American and Italian, Sicilian, Gluten Free, New York, etc)

Each style uses different tomato sauces, a variety of cheeses, and a very.very.very specific type of oven.

At Tony’s there are 7 different ovens “ranging from the Naples classic, burning wood to 900°, to a blistering 1000° coal oven, along with an assortment of gas and electric ovens, each perfectly suited to the particular style of pizza cooked in it.” –Forbes

So. Can I just tell you about how melty and absurdly meaty this Classic American Americano pizza is? Ugh. I love this pizza so much that I hate it.

I’m so full, it hurts.

Anyway. It’s made with mozzarella, pepperoni, salami, mushrooms, onions, bell peppers, (black olives), italian sausage, linguica, bacon, cherry tomatoes and scallions. This classic American pizza ($20) is made in a 550 degree gas oven, where I asked them to make it “extra crispy” (<– just the way I like it).


And THIS is the award winning “Best Pizza Margherita” at the World Pizza Cup in Naples, Italy.

They only make 73 of these per day. So naturally, I had to try it.

The dough is mixed by hand, using San Felice flour, topped with tomatoes, sea salt, mozzarella fior di latte, fresh basil, and extra virgin olive oil. The pizza is then heated in a 900 degree wood fired oven. ($19)

Like most margherita pizzas, this came out fast and with a super thin crust. While the mozzarella and sauce were in perfect balance, I do wish there was a little more flavor to this pizza (I guess i’m more of a meat, sausage, pepperoni kinda girl).

Last, we tried the Wild Robiola ($23), with mozzarella, burrata, robiola cheese, wild mushrooms, truffle oil, prosciutto, piave, and arugula. This California style pizza is made with caputo muti-grain dough, and is heated in a 900 degree wood fired oven.

I love the cheese they use on this pizza, and the dough had just the right balance of crispiness to chewiness. While this tasted great, and is a great alternative to tomato sauce, it’s a bit too rich and cheesy for me to eat that many slices.

To sum it all up, if you’re searching for a great pizzeria in San Francisco, then check out Tonys in North Beach. I’m sure you’ll find something on their extensive menu to satisfy any pizza cravings!

PS: Tonys draws in locals and tourists alike, so the lines are heavy during peak hours. Go early…or try to snag a seat at the bar!

Tony's Pizza Napoletana on Urbanspoon

Share it--->Share on FacebookTweet about this on TwitterPin on PinterestEmail to someoneGoogle+


  • […] Tony’s Pizza Napolenta (whoa) […]

  • Natalie September 30, 2014 - 6:32 pm Reply

    My BF and I came to Tonys after reading this post! We took your recommendation for the Americano pizza, and we both loved it very much. We even had left overs that we threw into the oven the next day. Thank you!

  • Chelsea T. September 25, 2014 - 6:02 pm Reply

    OMG your first picture looks amazing! Your blog makes me so hungry!

  • Marcus September 22, 2014 - 4:31 am Reply

    Definitely worth the wait. Get the Sausage and Stout, you wont be disappointed.

  • Henry September 19, 2014 - 5:27 pm Reply

    This place is amazing! Hands down, best pizza in san Francisco.

  • Giovanni September 17, 2014 - 8:07 pm Reply

    Ok, I came here from IG @mynutrifitchange and I have to say, I LOVE pizza. Being orignally from NYC, I’m biased towards the east coast having amazing Pizza, and living in southern California, I can never find a place that blows me away. I am making a trip to Sf coming up in a few weeks and I’m very excited. I am definitely going to be trying this place. The pizza looks amazing!!!

    • CynEats September 18, 2014 - 4:52 pm Reply

      I also heard that their “New Yorker” is one of their best pizzas (which I didn’t have room for). I guess you’ll have to be the judge of that! If you need any more foodie recommendations, let me know.

      PS: Golden Boy’s Pizza is right down the street…So if you can’t snag a seat at Tonys….go to Golden Boys! You won’t be disappointed :)

  • Molly T. September 15, 2014 - 5:42 pm Reply

    I loveeee pizza and this place is HEAVEN! I live in Sacramento, so every time I visit the city, I make sure to stop at Tonys!

  • Jennifer September 15, 2014 - 2:55 pm Reply

    The Margherita pizza is my favorite! The pizza is simple and has the perfect amount of cheese, sauce and basil!

  • Brittany September 15, 2014 - 10:50 am Reply

    Have you tried The New Yorker? I think it’s the best pizza on the menu. They use a tasty tomato sauce, ricotta and fennel sausage as toppings. It’s really good.

    • CynEats September 15, 2014 - 5:51 pm Reply

      I didn’t have room for The New Yorker this time, but I will definitely go back to try it! Thanks for the tip :)

    Leave a reply